Why is committing an offence on bail deemed to be aggravating?

Offences Committed While on Bail in NSW

Committing a further offence while on bail can have serious consequences. If the new offence is proved, the fact that it occurred while the person was on bail may be treated as an aggravating factor when the court determines the sentence.

Bail allows a person to remain in the community while criminal proceedings are underway. Further offending during that period can be regarded as an abuse of that liberty and may increase the need for deterrence.

For advice about obtaining bail, visit our Bail Applications page.

Why Is Offending While on Bail an Aggravating Factor?

Section 21A(2)(j) of the Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act 1999 (NSW) identifies offending while on conditional liberty in relation to an offence or alleged offence as an aggravating factor. Conditional liberty includes being released on bail.

This does not mean a person is presumed guilty of the original allegation. Rather, the court considers the circumstances in which the further offence was committed.

What Did the Court Say in R v Richards?

In R v Richards (1981) 2 NSWLR 464 at 465, Street CJ emphasised the need to protect the community from further offending by people released on bail.

His Honour explained that deterrent sentences may be appropriate where an offender abuses their freedom on bail. The judgment also addressed the importance of ensuring that additional offending attracts a meaningful sentencing consequence.

The principle remains relevant, but it does not create an automatic rule that every sentence must be served entirely on top of another sentence. The court must apply the relevant sentencing principles to the individual case.

Does Offending While on Bail Automatically Increase the Sentence?

There is no fixed additional penalty simply because an offence was committed on bail. The significance of that circumstance depends on the evidence, the offence and the applicable sentencing law.

Offending while on bail can also raise questions about compliance and whether continued release is appropriate. An allegation alone, however, is not a conviction for the new offence.

Is Further Offending the Same as Breaching a Bail Condition?

These are related but distinct issues. Committing a new offence concerns criminal conduct alleged to have occurred during release. Breaching a bail condition concerns failure to comply with a particular requirement of the bail decision.

The legal consequences depend on what occurred and the provisions that apply. A person facing either allegation should obtain advice promptly.

Speak with a Criminal Defence Lawyer

If you have been accused of committing an offence while on bail, George Sten & Co Criminal Lawyers can review the allegations, explain the potential consequences and advise on your options.

Call (02) 9261 8640 to arrange an appointment. For urgent criminal law assistance, call 0412 423 569, available 24 hours.