Affray Charges in NSW: Penalties and Defences
An affray charge is a serious criminal allegation that can carry a sentence of imprisonment. However, being present during a confrontation does not automatically make someone guilty. The prosecution must prove the legal elements of the offence beyond reasonable doubt.
George Sten & Co provides advice and representation for people facing affray charges in Sydney and throughout NSW. With more than 50 years’ experience in criminal law, our team can assess the evidence, explain your options and prepare your matter for court.
If you are in custody, our lawyers can assist with an urgent bail application, including advice about weekend bail applications.
Call (02) 9261 8640 during business hours. For urgent criminal law assistance, call 0412 423 569, available 24 hours.
What Is Affray?
Section 93C of the Crimes Act 1900 (NSW) makes it an offence to use or threaten unlawful violence towards another person where the conduct would cause a person of reasonable firmness at the scene to fear for their personal safety.
Section 93D also requires the accused to have intended to use or threaten violence, or to have been aware that their conduct might be violent or threaten violence.
Important features of the offence include:
- A threat cannot consist of words alone.
- No actual bystander needs to be present, or even likely to be present.
- Affray can occur in a private place as well as a public place.
- Where two or more people use or threaten unlawful violence, their conduct is considered together for the statutory safety test.
A person’s individual involvement and state of mind still require careful assessment.
What Does “A Person of Reasonable Firmness” Mean?
This is an objective test involving a hypothetical person at the scene. The court considers whether that person would fear for their own safety because of the conduct.
It is not necessary to identify an innocent bystander who actually became frightened. Equally, evidence that someone felt afraid does not, by itself, establish every element of affray.
The nature of the conduct and its surrounding circumstances are central to the assessment.
How Is Affray Different From Assault?
Affray and assault can arise from the same incident, but they have different legal requirements.
Assault concerns unlawful physical contact or, in appropriate circumstances, causing a person to apprehend immediate unlawful violence. Affray additionally requires the conduct to meet the reasonable-firmness test.
An incident involving violence is therefore not automatically affray. The prosecution must establish the requirements of the specific charge.
Examples of Conduct That May Amount to Affray
Depending on the circumstances, affray allegations may involve:
- A violent fight outside a licensed venue.
- Throwing a potentially injurious object towards another person.
- Advancing towards someone while making threatening physical gestures.
- Threatening someone with a weapon.
These are examples, rather than automatic findings of guilt. The lawfulness of the conduct, the accused’s state of mind and the reasonable-firmness test must all be considered.
For example, a person advancing towards another with raised fists while threatening violence may satisfy the requirements. A person merely standing nearby is not automatically responsible for that conduct.
Which Court Hears Affray Charges?
Affray is a Table 1 indictable offence. It is generally dealt with in the Local Court unless the prosecution or accused elects to have it dealt with on indictment.
Matters proceeding on indictment are ordinarily heard in the District Court.
The court dealing with the charge affects the available maximum penalty and the procedure your case follows.
What Are the Penalties for Affray?
The statutory maximum penalty is 10 years’ imprisonment. Where the offence is finalised in the Local Court, the maximum imprisonment for a single affray offence is two years.
These are maximum penalties, not the sentence imposed in every case.
The outcome depends on the seriousness of the conduct, the offender’s circumstances and the sentencing options legally available. Relevant matters may include the level of violence, any weapons or injuries, the person’s role, prior history, rehabilitation and a guilty plea.
What Defences or Disputed Issues May Arise?
The appropriate response depends on the evidence. Issues may include:
- Identification: whether the accused was correctly identified.
- Participation: whether the accused personally engaged in the alleged conduct.
- Unlawful violence: whether violence was used or threatened and whether it was unlawful.
- Words alone: whether the allegation involves only verbal threats.
- The safety test: whether the conduct would cause a person of reasonable firmness to fear for their safety.
- State of mind: whether the required intention or awareness can be proved.
Self-Defence
Self-defence may apply where a person believed their conduct was necessary to protect themselves or another person, and their response was reasonable in the circumstances as they perceived them.
Once self-defence is properly raised on the evidence, the prosecution must disprove it beyond reasonable doubt. Saying “I was defending myself” is not enough on its own; the surrounding evidence must be examined.
How Can George Sten & Co Criminal Lawyers Help?
Affray cases may involve conflicting accounts, fast-moving events and incomplete footage. We can review CCTV, witness statements, police material and other evidence to identify the issues that matter.
Our lawyers can advise whether to defend the charge, make representations to the prosecution or prepare a guilty plea and sentencing submissions.
Preserve relevant messages, recordings and witness details, and obtain advice before participating in a police interview.
Speak With an Affray Lawyer in Sydney
If you have been charged with affray, George Sten & Co can explain the allegation and help you prepare for the next stage.
Call (02) 9261 8640 or email us to arrange an appointment.
For urgent legal assistance, call 0412 423 569, available 24 hours.
Related Information on Affray
More information to come...
